Planet Gallifrey: Review: The Runaway Train

Saturday, October 2

Review: The Runaway Train

It's weird hearing Matt Smith's voice at first, but pretty soon, his vocal beauty sinks in and it becomes effortlessly entwined with the story. Fortunately for us, Matt's Texan twang is not as cheesy as one would expect. Amy's accent however... not so good. Thankfully, we don't hear her inconsistent babble as much (which is probably the best for the ears.) As Vin would say, "Docterr, that's completely insane."


All credit to composer Simon Hunt, whose wonderful work makes a delightfully creepy atmosphere to back the story. The quick, ominous thuds of thunderous thunder in tense, Western-esque scenes are very heart-jolting.

Oli Smith's masterful writing brings intrigue, as well as simplicity. The story is not overwritten and heavy, instead, it's light and easily understandable. He characterises the Doctor and Amy very well, and you can't help but just laugh at the awkward, zany comments the Doctor makes at the wrong times. Amy's feisty nature is certainly evident in this story, especially her encounter with a group of aggressive men (Eep.)


The only weakness lies during the fast-paced, action scenes (which are prevalent), where the listener would get a tad confused as to who is speaking. Again, Amy's voice comes into this example. Is she Scottish, Texas, American or Liverpudlian?

All in all, the audiobook is very pleasing and a promising start of what is to come.

PLANET GALLIFREY rates
THE RUNAWAY TRAIN
8/10

Out October 7th · Pre-order here.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

great review. i missed it when it came out with the daily telepgraph so i will get thus (:

Gagalett said...

FANTASTIC!

Oh, I mean...

GERONIMO!! Haha x

Anonymous said...

it was out already?

MacMachiavelli said...

Yup, with the Daily Telegraph as a promo copy. The real one is out on the 7th :)

BlushingRose said...

I got the promo copy,and I did enjoy it... but the "Pest Control" one, narrated by good 'ole DT, was better :P - apart from his version of Donna!

Anonymous said...

in the big bang episode i noticed a little girl with a red ballon maybe the family of blood is returning some how

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.