Planet Gallifrey: A Good Man Goes To War - A Review

Saturday, June 4

A Good Man Goes To War - A Review

[SPOILERS AHEAD]




What did you think? Tell us below!


There needn't be a review, considering around 6 million people are still speechless 'cause of that revelation.

As with many Moffat stories, the episode was closely knitted together with references to previous episodes, foreshadowings of future episodes, all the while masterfully intriguing the reader closer and closer to the TV screen. Throwing the audience into a realm of ambiguity and confusion right at the beginning is a pattern that has worked well with Moffat so far, but it's doubtful that this will be able to continue much longer before it becomes gimmicky. It was, however, beautifully done in this episode.


Bringing back characters from the previous series and episodes may have been a slight hint towards cutting down production costs, but it seems that most of the money went towards this episode. The unusual amount of extras and special effects compared to this-time-last-year gave the episode that extra push into the aesthetic brilliance which flourished in Series 4 and the finale to last year's series.

The only criticism I have is of the beginning, where Rory's part seemed a bit forced. Perhaps this was down to Arthur Darvill's acting style, or the writing, but the episode could have done without it. Having said that, the pre-titles shot of Rory (standing in front of an exploding Cyberman fleet) was amazingly shot.

There is only one question on our minds now... what happens next?!

✪✪✪✪✪

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

totally agree
!

John said...

I thought it was a rehash of all Moffat episodes esp. The Big Bang (#13)

Kate said...

<3

Anonymous said...

Voted!! :D@L:DL:D:D

Anonymous said...

Personally, the context of the episode was far too dense to have any sense of clarification with itself.

Anonymous said...

100% yes from me!

Lilly said...

It was a great episode + I really enjoyed watching it.

Gib said...

Great review as always

Kat^_^ said...

Not impressed. I think it was becaus I couldn't understand it ;D

Anonymous said...

Am I the only one that noticed Moffet's frequent hints that the Doctor was Melody's father!

Anonymous said...

That was epic... the cybermen got pwned... :O we got headless monks, more spitfires in space plus part 2 called "let's kill hitler" :D

Ironside vs Hitler :O

Anonymous said...

ikr :D:D

Unknown said...

Are you kidding! That was totally awesome! "I have a message from the Doctor and a question from me! Where is my wife!?!!" "What's the message?" (Entire CyberFleet starts blowing up behind him) "Do I need to repeat the question?" Brilliant. I loved the way Rory played it. It reminded me of his ferocity at the beginning of The Big Bang. Let's face it. Rory is a bit of a dork but when it comes to Amy's safety he can be a lion!

Anonymous said...

Can't wait till this airs in NZ! We're only up to 'The Doctors Wife', which airs this thursday. This series is already 100 times better than series 5.

Scots Red Mist said...

Kinda random, but still epic

itaintrite said...

Ok, I admit I didn't see this coming. But it was PRETTY obvious once you know the name of the baby to be Melody. Melody->Song. So yeah, didn't have to wait till end of episode for the revelation. It makes sense as well since all this has happened to River/Melody so she couldn't interfere.

AliBali said...

I felt it suffered from Moffatt's usual form in season finales.
He writes the Doctor as too much the great hero and he comes across as boastful and conceited.
Why does he need an army, he never needed one before?
I din't guess the twist, but I'm past caring to be honest - don't really feel for the characters.
Liked the Sontaran nurse though - inspired.

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.